The electric vehicle (EV) revolution has unexpectedly become entangled in broader cultural and political divides, often framed as an “us vs them” scenario. This polarization overlooks a fundamental truth: the people developing and championing EVs are often passionate car enthusiasts themselves.
Among car aficionados, skepticism towards EVs is common. Some feel pressured to adopt electric cars by external forces, while others simply prefer the traditional internal combustion engine (ICE). While legitimate criticisms of EVs exist—ranging from range limitations to the lack of a tangible emotional connection to the engine—these nuances often get lost in the broader narrative.
Numerous automotive journalists are observing this trend firsthand, engaging in conversations both online and within the industry. Through these interactions, a recurring pattern emerges: EV engineers and designers aren’t ideological opponents of traditional cars; they are simply excited about a new technology and its potential.
Consider the late Richard Parry-Jones, a highly regarded engineer at Ford who played a pivotal role in creating some of the company’s best-performing cars. He famously stated that the end of the “oil age” wouldn’t be due to running out of oil but rather because “we will have found a better solution.” Parry-Jones, a serious rally driver and dedicated car enthusiast, highlighted the inevitability of technological advancement within the automotive world.
This sentiment is reflected throughout the industry. Conversations with engineers at Porsche, Lucid, and elsewhere reveal a shared passion for cars, regardless of their powertrain. For example, Marco Schmerbeck at Porsche spoke with equal enthusiasm about the company’s new electric Cayenne and a previous project, the Audi R8. Similarly, Derek Jenkins, Lucid’s lead designer, proudly owns a Lotus Esprit S1, a testament to his appreciation for automotive design across different technologies.
Many enthusiasts personally own a variety of vehicles. The trend continues throughout the industry. It is no coincidence that the Lucid Air delivers a driving experience reminiscent of a BMW E39 5 Series, a clear indication of the design team’s appreciation for driving dynamics.
It’s understandable to cherish the visceral connection of a powerful engine and manual transmission. In fact, many EV advocates continue to appreciate and own traditional cars. The author recently purchased a five-speed 2002 BMW 325Ci, relishing the experience of its naturally aspirated straight-six engine.
However, the author also experienced a compelling realization while driving a Porsche Macan Electric. Despite driving aggressively and pushing its performance, the vehicle consistently achieved an impressive 3.78 miles/kWh—equivalent to 360 miles on a single charge—demonstrating the efficiency and capability of electric vehicles. It is easy to get caught up in comparing internal combustion engines with electric motors.
Ultimately, it is important to move beyond the false dichotomy of “us vs them.” Both internal combustion engines and electric vehicles have unique strengths and weaknesses, and the automotive world benefits from the innovation and passion brought by enthusiasts of both technologies.
The people creating electric cars aren’t opponents; they’re car lovers who see the potential of a new technology. It’s time to embrace a perspective of shared passion and recognize that the automotive world thrives on diversity and innovation—regardless of whether it’s powered by gasoline or electricity.
To stay informed about automotive trends, subscribe to our weekday newsletter. For more information, review our Privacy Policy & Terms of Use
